Deputation to the Oro-Medonte Council by the West Oro Ratepayers Association
November 2008
We are here speaking on behalf of the West Oro Ratepayers Association. WORA has a mailing list of 300 families and well over 130 paid members, but we try to represent the best interests of everyone who lives between Barrie, the 12th line, Horseshoe Valley Road and Lake Simcoe, members or not.
I am here to talk with you about the importance of some new laws for everyone who lives in and around Lake Simcoe. The economic stability of the area and the natural ecosystems which support the lake hang in the balance.
Oro-Medonte Council will be asked to submit a brief regarding support for the proposed Lake Simcoe Protection Act and Plan some time this fall. WORA and many of your constituents will be urging you to do the right thing and support the purpose of Bill 99: “An Act to protect and restore the ecological health of the Lake Simcoe watershed and to amend the Ontario Water Resources Act in respect of water quality trading.”
Recent initiatives such as the Greenbelt Act, Places to Grow Act, Clean Water Act and the Source Protection planning initiatives have been positive, but don’t make the mistake of believing that the Lake is now on the mend. Lake Simcoe is in trouble. I have provided a separate sheet outlining just some of the significant threats to our lake.
We want to make it clear here that the health of Lake Simcoe is absolutely bound to the economic health of our municipality. If the Lake continues to decline, tourism, cottaging, fishing and boating will also decline along with the economic spinoffs. When Oro-Medonte Council makes its submission to the Provincial Government about the Lake Simcoe Protection Act, the West Oro Ratepayers Association urges you to request the legislation include following seven essential elements:
1. A recreational policy that limits destructive activities and encourages sustainable ones.
2. No significant shoreline alteration and stricter controls on boathouse construction.
3. Preservation of natural areas that must cover 40 percent of the watershed with as much high quality natural cover as possible such as interior forests.
4. A policy that ensures a 100-metre buffer zone on shorelines and rivers (known as riparian corridors) precluding developments or changes damaging to the ecosystem.
5. A ten percent surface impermeability limit that supports ecosystem health and cold water fish.
6. Protection measures that have adequate and sustained funding.
7. Protection measures that are stringently enforced with a practical, fast-moving system.
Thank you for your time. Our delegation would be pleased to answer any questions you might have.
The West Oro Ratepayers Association
Some of the Current Threats to Lake Simcoe
The Lake has no recreation policy, no consistent shoreline management policy and, despite being perhaps the most intensively studied Lake in North America, will have no broad scale plan for protection until the Lake Simcoe Protection Plan is implemented.
Rapid growth in South Simcoe is in conflict with protecting the health of the Lake. An additional 250,000 people are expected to be added to the current population to reach the provincial target of 667,000 by 2031. Many expect the real increase could be double. The Lake will not survive this increase without careful management. All municipalities need to develop and adhere to a sustainable growth policy.
There are numerous large developments proposed for the Lake, but it is probably already above sustainable capacity for shoreline development and recreation. No matter what stage they are at in approvals, the new Lake Simcoe Protection Act should apply to all these developments.
The Assimilative Capacity Study model predicts an increase of 25 percent in phosphorus loading to an average of 82.5 tonnes per year in the committed future growth scenario for Lake Simcoe. This assumes similar precipitation patterns as occurred during the period from 1997 to 2004 and exceeds the current loading target for Lake Simcoe of 75 tonnes. The new phosphorus load target, based on scientific advice from the provincially-appointed science advisory committee, is likely to be much lower.
When more than ten percent of a lake’s shoreline is paved or covered in concrete, its ability to support cold water fish and general ecological health begins to be impaired. The impervious area in the Lake Simcoe area is currently at 15 percent and scheduled to increase.
WORA opposes in principle any ammendments to the Oro -Medonte Official Plan that would allow development (urban sprawl) outside of designated settlement areas. Development that converts natural wooded lands to a subdivision is contrary to Provincial Policy Statements and the County Official Plan while providing no benefit to Oro-Medonte. WORA would like to see Council impose a development freeze until the Lake Simcoe Protection Act is in place to ensure future projects meet the new standards.
There are 43 species at risk in the watershed. If we continue to destroy habitat as we are now, this list will grow.
Between 7,000 and 10,000 motor boats use Lake Simcoe every summer, but no one knows what the Lake’s ecological carrying capacity is for boat traffic. A developer wants to add another 1,000 slips at Big Bay Point, but the Lake may already be over capacity for boat traffic.
Many WORA members are concerned about the proliferation of large “cigar boats” on the Lake. These boats use large amounts of fuel and the noise disturbs both wildlife and residents over large distances.
Submitted by the West Oro Ratepayers Association, November 2008
|